data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a0d58/a0d586eec30b8f916818e8de6f64593d5e88ead5" alt=""
Geography isn't necessarily a reliable guide to how a whisky's going to taste, but if you decided that, since Old Pulteney is located in between Glenmorangie and Highland Park, that it would therefore lie somewhere between the two, taste-wise, it just so happens that you wouldn't be far wrong. It's got the same slightly shortbread-y, custard-y thing as the Glenmorangie (this will be because both whiskies are matured exclusively in American ex-bourbon casks, unlike the Highland Park which uses sherry casks, as does the Dalmore) with just a hint of something a bit darker and oilier, which might be licorice or might be tractor tyres or something like that. There's just a whiff of something salty like seaweed or herrings as well, and a waft of smoke just to keep things from being too sweet and undemanding. It's much lighter and more polite than the Highland Park, which is much more of a teeth-rattling slap in the chops with all the sherry wood and smoke, and remains my favourite thing ever, whisky-wise, but it's nonetheless really very good indeed. The distinctive knobbly bottle shape mimics the shape of the distillery stills, incidentally.
2 comments:
Accepting a degree of bias since I stay in Orkney, but after long deliberation and scientific testing (a glass of each in either hand sipped alternately), I have concluded that Scapa is the better of the two. Higher proof Scapa is even better.
You may very well be right - I've never tried the Scapa though as it's not widely available (i.e. not in Tesco's anyway!). I'm due to be passing through Birmingham airport in a few weeks so I intend a quick raid on their duty-free section.
Post a Comment