Monday, November 16, 2026

the last book I read

We Have Always Lived In The Castle by Shirley Jackson.

Meet Mary Katherine Blackwood. Or "Merricat" as she is known to her family, or was known to her family before most of them were wiped out in a poisoning incident a few years back. Only Merricat, big sister Constance and Uncle Julian remain, Constance somewhat scarred by being accused, and subsequently acquitted, of multiple murder (her parents and younger brother), and Uncle Julian somewhat scarred by the after-effects of being literally poisoned with arsenic and barely surviving. 

The surviving members of the Blackwood family live on in a great sprawling country house that's far too big for them, on the outskirts of a small town that feels like it's probably in New England, although it's never made clear (or not that I noticed, anyway). One of the after-effects of Constance's ordeal is that she now suffers from agoraphobia and never leaves the house, and so it falls to Merricat to venture into town a couple of times a week to buy supplies. She does not relish these trips as they are something of an ordeal, the townspeople being resentful of the Blackwoods' perceived wealth and snobbishness, and of the perception that Constance has probably got away with murder. 

On the upside, Constance is an excellent cook and housekeeper and devoted to Merricat, despite her bizarre habit of secreting various totemic items around the garden and grounds of the house in an attempt to ward off bad omens; Constance is also devoted to Uncle Julian despite his physical incapacity and obsessive writing and rewriting of his notes concerning the events on the day of the poisoning.

So the family muddles along in its own eccentric way with only very infrequent visitors, until the routine is broken one day by the arrival of Charles Blackwood, Constance and Merricat's cousin. Kept away up to now out of obligation to his parents (there'd been some family dispute) but now freed by their deaths to do as he pleases he has turned up to see what the family is up to. Not, it turns out, just out of generosity or curiosity but also because he believes there is a substantial fortune locked away in the house somewhere, probably in the drawing-room safe. 

Charles is a bit loud and vulgar, and impatient with both Merricat and Uncle Julian, but Constance starts to warm to him and to express an interest in the world outside the house and its grounds. Merricat, on the other hand, decides that he will definitely have to go, and if he won't just conclude his business and leave then some persuasion might be required. So when dumping a load of water and garden waste into his bed doesn't work she has the bright idea of knocking his lit pipe into a waste-paper basket and setting the whole house on fire. 

Help eventually arrives and the fire is extinguished, but not before it has consumed half of the house. To add to the destruction a group of curious townspeople has followed the fire-trucks in and takes the opportunity to ransack the house. All this is too much for old Uncle Julian and he dies of a massive heart attack; Merricat and Constance take refuge in one of Merricat's secret hideouts (hidesout, if you must) in the woods until the fuss dies down, and then return to the house to see what can be salvaged. The kitchen is pretty much intact and there's just about enough room elsewhere to sleep, and so Merricat and Constance settle into an even more reduced existence, eventually boarding up the front windows to prevent prying by curious visitors, allowing climbing plants to overrun the outer walls, and passing into local legend as a witchy cautionary tale to scare the kids with. 

Although the town the Blackwood house is on the outskirts of is never named, the smart and observant reader won't have to get far beyond the arresting opening paragraph here to deduce that we are definitely in Unreliable Narratorsville:

The same smart and observant reader won't have to get much further into the book to deduce that there's something a bit rum going on with the poisoning event (six years before the book's nominal "now"), and that same reader will probably permit themselves a smug pat on the back when it's conclusively revealed while Merricat and Constance are hiding out in the woods after the fire that it was in fact Merricat who did the poisoning, Constance taking the rap to protect her. It's never very clear exactly what the parents and brother did to irritate Merricat enough to murder them, nor how she got hold of the arsenic, but it is in the nature of people with psychopathic tendencies that the triggering event doesn't necessarily have to be anything big. 

Shirley Jackson is probably best-known for her supernatural novel The Haunting Of Hill House, made into two films both called The Haunting, firstly in 1963 and then again in 1999. I saw the older black-and-white film well over thirty years ago and recall it being pretty scary in a weird and atmospheric sort of way. The only caveat I'd offer is that I saw it as part of a season of old classic supernatural films and may be partly mixing it up with The Innocents which I saw around the same time. I haven't seen the newer film but it looks somewhat more lurid. Jackson's early short story The Lottery was also a minor sensation at the time of its publication and seems to have heavily influenced Stephen King's Children Of The Corn.

Anyway, back to We Have Always Lived In The Castle - this was Jackson's last published novel before her early death (aged 48) in 1965. It's wickedly sly and funny despite the central character being clearly a monster who has dragged her well-meaning sister down with her. Some of the themes - close-knit family, siblings sharing a dark secret, murders covered up - are reminiscent of The Other, although the tone here is much drier and ironic and less hysterical. There are some echoes of Rebecca as well, I suppose: big country house, deaths in the past suddenly being thrown into a new perspective. Anyway, it's very good and I recommend it, and at 146 pages in my Penguin Modern Classics paperback edition you should whizz through it in no time. 

I've mentioned before that I quite like to follow a big thick intimidating book with a short one, as a sort of palate cleanser, and I contend that this (729 pages) is probably the greatest page differential between successive books in the history of this list. A quick check instantly reveals that this would be incorrect, though, and in hindsight it should have been obvious that the winner would be whichever book I read immediately after Infinite Jest. Here are all the ones I could find with a page differential of more than 500:


No comments: